Clutch May Wear Prematurely on Mini Cooper S

There are reports of premature clutch wear on cars equipped with manual transmissions.  Clutch replacement on these vehicles can be quite costly.

RepairPal Verified
Average mileage: 43,376 (17,000–87,578)
Drive Train affected: Manual Transmission
8 model years affected: 2002, 2003, 2005, 2006, more2007, 2008, 2009, 2012
26 people reported this problem
Get Your Car Fixed at a RepairPal Certified Shop.
We certify shops based on expertise, quality work, and verified customer reviews
Viewing 1 - 20 of 21 problem details
2009 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 28,000 mi,
I am shocked! I have less than 30K miles on my mini - it is driven very limited and I started to experience some drag on the clutch when driving - as well as a loud screech - I took the car to Mini yesterday and they called me today to tell me the clutch has gone out -- I also purchased the extended warranty - however this is NOT covered by extended warranty as it is considered normal wear and tear........ Really? They now want me to spend $3000 for a new clutch -- outrageous.....
2012 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 41,732 mi,
Clutch slipping
2009 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 17,000 mi,
Bought the car used with 9600 miles. Now 17000 and the clutch is going out. Dealer says I should buy an extended maintenance warranty to cover the cost ($3200 just for the clutch replacement, $2000 for the warranty). What a ripoff!
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 18,000 mi,
Clutch worn out at 18,000 miles. Replaced and then wore out again at 33,000 miles. Dealer said it is the hills in San Francisco.
2009 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 50,000 mi,
I bought this car used with 17,000. At 36,000 I had to replace the clutch. This was covered under the additional maintenance warranty that I bought for $2500. Now the car has just over 50,000 (i.e. no maintenance warranty) and I am being told the clutch only has 25% of life left in it and needs to be replaced again. I called my mini dealer and they said this is a wear and tear part and is due to how I drive the car. I am not sure how the first clutch can last 36,000 and this one only last 14,000. They suggested that I call Mini USA. I did so and asked them to cover the cost of this clutch. They are looking into the issue and will advise but told me it was unlikely as it is a wear and tear item. I mentioned the vast number of online posts about premature clutch wear in a mini and they said they understood my complaint. They will advise in 3-5 days by which time I will have paid for and collected my vehicle.
2006 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 87,578 mi,
I bought the car used and two days later the clutch burnt out.
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 61,000 mi,
Two repair shops have alerted me to a potential clutch replacement. At 61,000, that is perhaps when a clutch should be replaced. The quote of $2,900 from the MINI dealer does not seem to be a reasonable repair cost though. This site shows estimates between $1,200-$2,400, so I will shop different repair sites listed on this site.
2008 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 38,000 mi,
Started having a "burning clutch smell" about a week ago, today sound of metal/clutch slipping. Car is 7.5 years old but only 38K miles. Given that I've had to have the engine walnut blasted (once under warranty), the tension bracket on the timing belt replaced, the water pump recalled, and now the airbags recalled - yeah, whomever said BMW went cheap on the engineering for this car had it nailed. Getting it fixed and then selling it to someone who cares more for the pep and look than maintenance.
2012 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 30,000 mi,
Felt clutch slipping and took the vehicle in for service around 30,000 mi.
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 40,000 mi,
Clutch failed at 40,000 miles
2009 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 27,000 mi,
Clutch went out at 27K--- dealership told me this was considered normal wear and tear..... really?
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 38,000 mi,
Driven MT cars for 35 years, so I know what I am doing. Had this as original owner since 2007. A year ago the clutch pedal seemed high but otherwise worked OK. Lately, the clutch began slipping whenever accelerating, easy to hear and feel, especially when shifting into 3 or 4 merging onto the freeway. Hello, MINI?? Do you see a disaster in the making? This is AFTER I had my car repaired 5,000 miles ago for the timing chain tensioner fault which put me back $2,400 after I complained about a much higher price for the repair. FYI, I am diligent about maintenance, etc.
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 46,000 mi,
My clutch failed on our 2007 Cooper S, I think it should last more than 45,000 miles
2012 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 42,000 mi,
Burning clutch smell, friction point rising ( too much play in pedal ), mushy or bumpy feeling at the bottom of pedal travel. Fighting with dealer on diagnosis and solution. I was told to pay for whatever it was out of pocket.
2009 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 27,458 mi,
Noticed pulling from a stop 1st gear it's very sluggish and it does not engage.
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 32,000 mi,
On the expressway in 5th or 6th rear, when accelerating the RPMs would increase but you wouldn't feel the car pull the same way as it use to. Reversing or starting out in 1st you could feel a rough shake as you engaged the clutch. I gave in once I heard the metal rivets in the clutch disc engaging the clutch plates. There was nearly no clutch disc material left. Noticed all this around 30k miles.
2003 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 22,000 mi,
clutch went with 22k miles
2007 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 67,000 mi,
Cooper S, very careful on the clutch it started to slip and was gone in under a week. We live in central Ohio, very flat.
2009 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 41,000 mi,
Had the auxiliary water pump cooler installed per recall and transmission started slipping shortly after. DSC module went out and that was replaced under warranty. Still had the slipping issue. Now they are saying the clutch may be going out and not covered under warranty. None of the problems started till the auxiliary water pump cooler was installed.
2008 Mini Cooper S - Manual Transmission 80,000 mi,
Just purchased this car used TWO WEEKS ago. The "warranty" was for 15 days. On the 17th day, the clutch went out completely. Slow to accellerate from stop sign, and then didn't move at all. Revved, shifted, but didn't move, and a very hot burning smell. I could have been killed in the middle of the intersection. Now the dealer where I purchased the car is giving me grief about it being after the warranty. By TWO days. Even tho this issue started a few days ago, it just didn't DIE until today. I am disgusted.