2009 Toyota Highlander Is Leaking Oil

Address Oil Leaks in Your 2009 Toyota Highlander Effectively

Find Repair Location
Reviewed by
Bo Fader
Written by RepairPal Car Genius
Updated January 14, 2025
0%
80% chance it's the
Oil System Components
0%
20% chance it's the
Engine Gaskets
The most common reasons a 2009 Toyota Highlander is leaking oil are oil system component failure and leaking engine gaskets.
  • Oil System Components: A worn or damaged oil pump or filter can lead to low oil pressure, resulting in inadequate lubrication and potential engine damage.
  • Engine Gaskets: A worn or damaged engine gasket can lead to oil or coolant leaks, resulting in engine overheating or loss of lubrication.
Proper diagnosis will determine the exact cause of your symptom, saving you money on unnecessary repairs. The diagnostic experts at RepairPal Certified shops have the right tools and experience to solve any symptom.

How much does it cost to fix a 2009 Toyota Highlander is leaking oil?

Common Repairs

The total repair cost will vary based on the condition of your vehicle and the number of repairs needed to fix your symptom. Proper diagnosis will save you money by finding the exact repairs needed to fix your car right the first time.

Oil pans don't wear out or break like other parts, they generally only need to be replaced because of external damage from an accident or an improperly tightened drain plug. The main symptom you will experience is an oil leak underneath the engine of your car. The oil that leaks from a damaged oil pan will range from dark brown to dark black. If the leak is large enough or occurs for long enough the oil level will be low enough to turn the oil pressure or low oil level warning light on.

An oil leak may be noted on the ground where the vehicle is parked. However, many vehicles have plastic trays underneath the engine that may catch leaking oil and conceal the leak. In such cases, a low oil level, a burning oil smell, or even smoke from oil burning in the engine bay may be noted.

»MORE: Signs of a bad oil pan gasket

The engine oil pressure warning light will come on if the engine oil pressure is low, or if the oil pressure sensor is faulty. In either case, engine power may be reduced significantly. The check engine light may also illuminate, and an on-board diagnostic (OBD) trouble code will be stored in the vehicle's computer.

What are the steps to diagnose the oil leak in a 2009 Toyota Highlander?

To effectively diagnose an oil leak in your 2009 Toyota Highlander, start by locating the leak. Begin by inspecting the area where you typically park your vehicle for any oil puddles or drips, which can help you identify the source of the leak. Next, check the oil level in the engine; a significant drop may indicate a leak that needs attention. Pay close attention to the oil filter and drain plug, as these components are common culprits for leaks—tightening or replacing them can often resolve the issue. Additionally, examine the gaskets and seals around the engine for signs of wear or damage, as compromised seals can lead to leaks. If the source remains elusive, consider performing a pressure test, which can help pinpoint leaks that are not immediately visible. Should you still be unable to identify the problem, consulting a mechanic is advisable for a professional assessment and repair. By following this diagnostic approach, you can systematically address the issue and ensure your Highlander remains in optimal condition.

What are the common causes of oil leaks in a 2009 Toyota Highlander?

When dealing with oil leaks in a 2009 Toyota Highlander, it's essential to understand the common culprits that may be at play. One frequent issue is the deterioration of the oil pan gasket, which can wear out over time, leading to leaks. Similarly, the valve cover gasket is another critical component that can degrade, resulting in oil seeping from the top of the engine. Additionally, a faulty oil filter housing gasket can cause leaks near the oil filter, while the rear main seal, if worn, can lead to oil escaping from the back of the engine. Lastly, don’t overlook the oil cooler lines, as leaks in these lines are also a common source of oil leaks in this model. Addressing these issues promptly is vital to prevent further damage and maintain the vehicle's performance, making regular inspections and maintenance key to early detection and resolution of oil leaks.

How urgent is it to address the oil leak in my 2009 Toyota Highlander?

Addressing an oil leak in your 2009 Toyota Highlander is not just a matter of routine maintenance; it is a pressing issue that requires immediate attention. Ignoring an oil leak can lead to a cascade of problems, including reduced oil levels that compromise the lubrication of essential engine components. This lack of lubrication increases friction and wear, which can escalate into severe engine damage and costly repairs. Moreover, oil that leaks onto hot engine parts poses a significant fire hazard, creating safety risks for you and your passengers. Additionally, an oil leak can adversely affect your vehicle's performance, leading to decreased fuel efficiency and overall engine functionality. Therefore, it is crucial to act swiftly and address any signs of an oil leak to maintain the safety, efficiency, and longevity of your Toyota Highlander.

You’ve got options with RepairPal

Whether you need a more accurate auto repair estimate or help finding a reputable shop in your area, we’ve got you covered.

2009 Toyota Highlander Oil Leak Causes & Repairs | RepairPal