2009 Subaru Legacy Is Leaking Oil

Discovering the Causes of Oil Leaks in Your 2009 Subaru Legacy and How to Fix Them Effectively

Find Repair Location
Reviewed by
Devin Cabugcal
Written by RepairPal Car Genius
Updated January 14, 2025
0%
80% chance it's the
Oil System Components
0%
20% chance it's the
Engine Gaskets
The most common reasons a 2009 Subaru Legacy is leaking oil are oil system component failure and leaking engine gaskets.
  • Oil System Components: A worn or damaged oil pump or filter can lead to low oil pressure, resulting in inadequate lubrication and potential engine damage.
  • Engine Gaskets: A worn or damaged engine gasket can lead to oil or coolant leaks, resulting in engine overheating or loss of lubrication.
Proper diagnosis will determine the exact cause of your symptom, saving you money on unnecessary repairs. The diagnostic experts at RepairPal Certified shops have the right tools and experience to solve any symptom.

How much does it cost to fix a 2009 Subaru Legacy is leaking oil?

Common Repairs

The total repair cost will vary based on the condition of your vehicle and the number of repairs needed to fix your symptom. Proper diagnosis will save you money by finding the exact repairs needed to fix your car right the first time.

The engine oil pressure warning light will come on if the engine oil pressure is low, or if the oil pressure sensor is faulty. In either case, engine power may be reduced significantly. The check engine light may also illuminate, and an on-board diagnostic (OBD) trouble code will be stored in the vehicle's computer.

What are the steps to diagnose an oil leak in a 2009 Subaru Legacy?

When diagnosing an oil leak in a 2009 Subaru Legacy, it's essential to adopt a methodical diagnostic approach that prioritizes simpler solutions before delving into more complex issues. Begin by cleaning the engine thoroughly to eliminate any old oil residue, which will help you pinpoint the new leak more effectively. After cleaning, consider adding UV dye to the oil system; this will illuminate the source of the leak when you run the engine and inspect it with a UV light. Focus your inspection on common leak areas such as the valve cover gaskets, head gaskets, and the oil pan, as these are frequent culprits in Subaru vehicles. Conduct a visual inspection of the oil filter area and the timing belt cover, looking for any signs of oil accumulation or drips. Pay attention to the exhaust and heat shields, as oil leaks can lead to burning smells if oil drips onto hot components. If you’re unable to identify the leak after these steps, consulting a mechanic with experience in Subaru vehicles can provide further insights, especially for concealed leaks that may require disassembly for proper diagnosis. By following this structured approach, you can effectively identify and address the oil leak in your Subaru Legacy.

What are the common causes of oil leaks in a 2009 Subaru Legacy?

When dealing with oil leaks in a 2009 Subaru Legacy, it's crucial to understand the various components that may be at fault. One of the most common culprits is the valve cover gasket, which can deteriorate over time, leading to noticeable leaks. Inspecting the valve cover area for tightness in the bolts can often reveal if this is the source of the problem. Another frequent issue arises from the camshaft seals, located behind the camshaft sprockets; these seals can wear out, especially the older black versions, necessitating replacement. Additionally, the crank seal and rear main seal are known to fail, causing oil to leak onto lower engine components, which can be a messy situation. While oil pan gaskets are less frequently the source of leaks, they can still be problematic if bolts are loose or if the gasket itself is damaged. It's also important to check the oil cooler lines and the power steering system, as leaks from these areas can sometimes be mistaken for engine oil. Lastly, while head gasket failures are more notorious for mixing fluids, they can also lead to external oil leaks, particularly in the 2.5L engines. For those looking to tackle these issues themselves, a thorough inspection of these components can help pinpoint the source of the leak, but consulting a Subaru specialist may be beneficial for a comprehensive diagnosis.

How urgent is it to address the oil leak in a 2009 Subaru Legacy?

Addressing an oil leak in your 2009 Subaru Legacy should not be taken lightly, as the urgency of the situation can significantly impact your vehicle's performance and longevity. Even if the leak appears minor, it can lead to increased oil consumption and potential damage to critical engine components over time. Common sources of oil leaks, such as valve cover gaskets or oil pan gaskets, may seem less urgent, but they can escalate into more serious issues if left unattended. Particularly concerning are leaks from the head gasket, which can cause severe engine damage if not addressed promptly. Ignoring these symptoms can result in costly repairs and even safety risks, as oil exposure can damage other parts of the vehicle. Therefore, it is crucial to have a professional mechanic assess the situation to determine the source of the leak and recommend timely repairs, ensuring your Subaru remains reliable and safe on the road.

You’ve got options with RepairPal

Whether you need a more accurate auto repair estimate or help finding a reputable shop in your area, we’ve got you covered.

2009 Subaru Legacy Oil Leak Causes & Repair Estimates