2005 Subaru Legacy Has A Rattling Noise

Diagnosing Common Causes of Rattling Noises in Your 2005 Subaru Legacy and How to Fix Them

Find Repair Location
Reviewed by
Andrew Hajjar
Written by RepairPal Car Genius
Updated January 14, 2025
0%
28% chance it's the
Ball Joints
0%
16% chance it's the
Struts or Strut Mount
0%
12% chance it's the
Sway Bar Links
0%
44% chance it's
Something else
The most common reasons a 2005 Subaru Legacy has a rattling noise are the ball joints, struts or strut mount, or a problem with the sway bar links.
  • Ball Joints: A worn or damaged ball joint can result in poor steering response and uneven tire wear due to compromised suspension geometry.
  • Struts or Strut Mount: A worn or damaged strut or strut mount can result in poor ride quality, excessive noise, and uneven tire wear.
  • Sway Bar Links: A worn or damaged sway bar link can result in excessive body roll and clunking noises during turns.
Proper diagnosis will determine the exact cause of your symptom, saving you money on unnecessary repairs. The diagnostic experts at RepairPal Certified shops have the right tools and experience to solve any symptom.

What steps should I take to diagnose the rattling noise in my 2005 Subaru Legacy?

To effectively diagnose the rattling noise in your 2005 Subaru Legacy, start with a systematic approach that prioritizes simpler checks before delving into more complex issues. Begin by inspecting the transmission and gearbox, as noises during gear changes may indicate fluid problems or internal wear. Next, examine the exhaust system for loose hangers or damaged heat shields, which are common culprits for rattling sounds at various speeds. Pay special attention to the rear suspension and frame, particularly if the noise seems localized to that area; worn bushings or loose components can create unsettling sounds. Conduct a thorough visual and auditory inspection, listening for changes in the noise under different driving conditions, as this can provide critical clues. If you have access to a repair manual or an OBD-II scanner, utilize these resources to check for diagnostic codes that may point to underlying issues. By following this structured diagnostic approach, you can effectively narrow down the source of the rattling noise and determine the necessary steps for resolution.

What could be causing the rattling noise in my 2005 Subaru Legacy?

When diagnosing a rattling noise in your 2005 Subaru Legacy, it's essential to consider several common problems that could be the source of the issue. One of the primary culprits is the exhaust system, where components like the catalytic converter or muffler may be malfunctioning, especially if recent repairs were made. Additionally, inspect the suspension and steering components, as worn or loose parts such as ball joints and struts can create similar noises. Engine-related issues, particularly piston slap in the DOHC engine, may also lead to rattling sounds, particularly noticeable at idle. If your model is turbocharged, a faulty turbocharger could be the cause, often accompanied by other performance issues. Lastly, while less likely, interior rattles can occur due to temperature changes affecting dashboard materials. To effectively troubleshoot, pay attention to the noise's location and the conditions under which it occurs, and consider any recent maintenance that might have contributed to the problem. If you're unable to identify the source, consulting a mechanic experienced with Subaru vehicles can provide clarity and guidance on necessary repairs.

How urgent is it to address the rattling noise in my 2005 Subaru Legacy?

When it comes to addressing a rattling noise in your 2005 Subaru Legacy, understanding the urgency of the situation is crucial. Engine-related noises, especially those resembling a diesel engine at idle, can indicate serious underlying issues, such as valve problems that could lead to significant engine damage if left unchecked. Even if the noise seems minor, it’s essential to recognize that it may be a symptom of a more severe problem that could escalate over time, resulting in costly repairs or even engine failure. Noises originating from the undercarriage, like those related to heat shields or U joints, while potentially less urgent, can still lead to embarrassing situations and further complications if not addressed promptly. Therefore, regardless of the perceived severity of the noise, it is advisable to consult a mechanic as soon as possible. This proactive approach not only ensures your vehicle's safety but also helps prevent minor issues from developing into major repairs, ultimately saving you time and money in the long run.

You’ve got options with RepairPal

Whether you need a more accurate auto repair estimate or help finding a reputable shop in your area, we’ve got you covered.

Diagnosing Rattling Noises in Your 2005 Subaru Legacy