Choosing between a 2005 Toyota Matrix and a 2005 (or 2004) Subaru Outback mainly depends on your priorities and specific needs. Both vehicles have their strengths and weaknesses, so let's break down the factors you should consider:
1. Safety: Both the Toyota Matrix and Subaru Outback are generally considered safe vehicles. They have received decent safety ratings, but the Outback might have an advantage due to Subaru's reputation for building sturdy and reliable vehicles, often equipped with all-wheel drive, which can be beneficial in certain weather conditions. However, individual crash test ratings and safety features might vary depending on the specific trim and options.
2. Space: Since you mentioned needing more room than your Yaris, both the Matrix and Outback should offer increased cargo space and passenger room. The Outback is generally larger, providing more space for both passengers and belongings. However, the Matrix might still be sufficient, especially if you find it more comfortable to drive.
3. Reliability: Toyota has a strong reputation for building reliable vehicles, and the Matrix is no exception. Similarly, Subaru is known for making durable cars, and the Outback has proven to be a popular and long-lasting model. However, as both vehicles are older (around 2005), it becomes more important to consider the maintenance history and condition of each individual car. Regular maintenance and a well-documented service history are essential.
4. All-Wheel Drive (AWD): If you expect to encounter challenging weather conditions or enjoy outdoor activities, having an AWD system can be advantageous. The Subaru Outback typically comes with AWD, which could be a significant factor in its favor if you value enhanced traction and stability.
5. Fuel Efficiency: Generally, the Toyota Matrix tends to have better fuel efficiency compared to the Subaru Outback. This might not be the deciding factor for you, but it's worth considering if you have specific concerns about gas mileage.
6. Handling and Driving Experience: This can be subjective, but you might want to test-drive both vehicles to see which one you feel more comfortable driving, especially in city environments like Brooklyn.
Considering you're traveling with four cats and your wife, it's crucial to prioritize their comfort and safety as well.
Given that both cars are in pretty similar condition, it would be wise to have a trusted mechanic inspect the specific vehicles you are considering before making a decision. Additionally, obtaining vehicle history reports and researching any potential recalls can give you a better idea of the cars' past.
Ultimately, the "better" choice depends on your personal preferences and priorities. If you value AWD and slightly more space, the Outback could be a safer bet. If fuel efficiency and Toyota's renowned reliability are more important to you, the Matrix might be the better option. Remember to factor in any potential maintenance costs and the condition of each car to make an informed decision.
Lastly, make sure to check for any relevant local regulations or restrictions that might apply to traveling with pets in your area.
Whatever your choice, I wish you a safe and pleasant driving experience with your new vehicle!
