What would cause a hydraulic pump (for convertible top operation) to fail?

What is your question?

I recently took my car to the dealership for a different service (replacement of the auxiliary heat pump) and drove into the service bay with the convertible top down before closing it to leave the car for the heat pump replacement work. When I returned to retrieve the car after the completion of the auxiliary heat pump replacement, I attempted to operate the convertible top to open the top when preparing to leave the dealer's service center and it would not open. After an inspection and diagnostic test by the technician at the dealer's service center they claimed the hydraulic pump was no longer working and needed to be replaced. The car is a 2012 BMW 650 with 38K miles. What are the possible causes for the hydraulic pump to fail without warning or intervention/use? Can an electrical surge or short by improper connection of service center equipment be a potential cause (or something similar)?

gcounts51 in Washington DC

·

Jun 17, 2018

·

1 Reply

Popular Answer
casey40510on Jun 19, 2018

Hello, Not fun, I know that is a costly repair. Even worse, it may not be diagnosed correctly. I advise taking it to a good independent BMW shop for diagnosis, and see if they come up with the same problem. No, I wouldn't associate the repair of the engine cooling system or heater to the convertible top hydraulic pump failing.

Reply
gcounts51on Jun 21, 2018

Thank you for the recommendation. I will look for an independent BMW shop in my area. Thanks again-

Reply in Thread

Join the conversation!

Sign in or create an account to respond

Reply

Similar Questions

See more 2012 BMW 650i Questions

What are the best BMW repair shops?

RepairPal Certified shops can diagnose and repair your 2012 BMW 650i. They provide transparent pricing with a minimum 12-month or 12,000-mile warranty on repairs and services.
28 Certified Locations
Shop Image

Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center - Grandview

4.7
(81)
2.39 mi
1524 W 5th Ave
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 8:00 AM Sat
Call
Shop Image

Excite Auto Repair & Towing

4.4
(15)
5.94 mi
3430 Westerville Road
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 9:00 AM Mon
Call
Shop Image

All In Auto Service

4.9
(21)
6.56 mi
5200 Fisher Road
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 8:00 AM Mon
Call
Shop Image

Tuffy Tire & Auto Service - Grove City

4.4
(520)
6.67 mi
2131 Stringtown Rd
Grove City, OH
Closed
Opens 8:00 AM Sat
Call
Shop Image

Blackstone Complete Auto Care

4.2
(35)
6.77 mi
4800 Sinclair Road
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 9:00 AM Sat
Call
Shop Image

Boyd's Tire & Service - Columbus

4.7
(178)
7.23 mi
5263 Godown Rd
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 8:00 AM Sat
Call
See All 28 Locations
28 Certified Locations
Shop Image

Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center - Grandview

4.7
(81)
2.39 mi
1524 W 5th Ave
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 8:00 AM Sat
Call
Shop Image

Excite Auto Repair & Towing

4.4
(15)
5.94 mi
3430 Westerville Road
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 9:00 AM Mon
Call
Shop Image

All In Auto Service

4.9
(21)
6.56 mi
5200 Fisher Road
Columbus, OH
Closed
Opens 8:00 AM Mon
Call
See All 28 Locations