Mini Cooper starter failure with solenoid issues, requires replacement after intermittent engagement on Mini Cooper

Submitted by DawgsinFL · Jun 23, 2025
Published by RepairPal

Problem overview

Some MINI Cooper owners report experiencing starter failure due to solenoid issues, which often require replacement after intermittent engagement. Common faults can arise from problematic components such as the starter motor, engine control unit (ECU), sensors, wiring, and immobilizer during start-up. Signs of a malfunctioning starter solenoid include the engine failing to crank when the key is turned. Additionally, a weak battery may cause a repetitive clicking sound from the starter solenoid, indicating potential issues with the starter or its wiring. Intermittent engine start problems, especially accompanied by warnings like "Engine Start only possible when no gear is engaged," may signal underlying issues that need immediate attention. To diagnose and address these starter-related problems, owners are advised to check battery voltage, starter motor connections, and ensure secure ground connections. Promptly addressing these issues is crucial to prevent further complications and ensure the vehicle's proper functioning.

8 people reported this problem
4 comments
Schedule Repair

Mini Cooper vehicles with this problem

Average mileage: 111,902 miles
(56,000 - 180,199)

Search for another problem

RepairPal Car Genius

Ask our experts about your Mini.

RepairPal Car Genius™ is a free resource for vehicle owners seeking advice on maintenance, auto repair, shop inquiries, estimates, and finding a trustworthy repair shop in your area.

 Auto Repair Expert Auto Repair Expert

Call us at 877-913-1554

Available 9am – 6pm ET Monday through Friday

Call Our Experts