Subaru Forester head gasket oil leak issue requiring replacement on Subaru Forester

Submitted by Vehicle Owner · Feb 19, 2026
Published by RepairPal

Problem overview

Some Subaru Forester owners report experiencing head gasket oil leak issues that require replacement, which can manifest as external oil leaks, internal coolant leaks, or warped and cracked heads. Symptoms such as coolant mixing with engine oil or a milky white appearance on the oil dipstick may indicate a head gasket problem. Many owners find that head gasket leaks are a common occurrence in Subaru vehicles, particularly in models with the EJ253 engine, where external oil leaks may not be immediately noticeable. The average cost for head gasket replacement is reported to range from $2,000 to $4,000, with labor being a significant part of the expense, and additional parts like tensioners and seals potentially increasing overall costs. Some owners also consider preventive measures, such as replacing the rear main seal and cam seals during the head gasket replacement process. Additionally, Subaru has made design changes in later models, like the FB25 engine, to reduce the risk of oil and coolant mixing by altering the coolant flow through the head gasket.

2 people reported this problem
0 comments
Schedule Repair

Subaru Forester vehicles with this problem

1 model year affected
Average mileage: 55,000 miles
(55,000 - 55,000)

Search for another problem

RepairPal Car Genius

Ask our experts about your Subaru.

RepairPal Car Genius™ is a free resource for vehicle owners seeking advice on maintenance, auto repair, shop inquiries, estimates, and finding a trustworthy repair shop in your area.

 Auto Repair Expert Auto Repair Expert

Available 9am – 6pm ET Monday through Friday

Call Our Experts
© 2026 RepairPal, Inc. RepairPal® RepairPal Certified®