Close
Car Questions
RepairPal is your advocate for car care advice and guidance

Pcv valve replacement.

(2000 BMW 528i)
in Columbia, SC on February 01, 2011
mechanic told me that i need to replace the pcv valve.... i dont know how he came to this, but auto is running rough.
auto has 215m miles ... sometimes feel a miss, and sometimes a lunge(at stop light)... otherwise still going ok... must keep driving, but mech insist that performance would improve with this pcv thing.... approx est cost 550.00...... i cannot find pcv replacement on your website. thanks donwalters
Displaying 1 answers & 3 comments
Popular Answer
on February 01, 2011
Bad PCV could cause these symptoms, since unmeasured air enters into the intake.
PCV (Crankcase Vent Valve) could be tested by a manometer.
It's from the BMW repair manual:
A properly functioning pressure control valve is designed to maintain a slight vacuum (approximately 10 - 15 mbar ) in the crankcase which assures reliable crankcase venting during all engine operating conditions.

A malfunctioning crankcase ventilation valve may cause the following complaints:

* Engine runs rough
* Whistling noise from crankcase ventilation valve
* Check engine light on - possible DME faults stored: misfire all cylinders, oxygen sensor/mixture faults, etc.

You can do this:
While the motor is running at normal operating temperatures, loosen up the oil filler cap and try to lift it up. If there is a strong vacuum sucking the cap back, the PCV valve is bad.

I don't know if their estimate includes all the vent hoses, I'd strongly suggest to replace those also.

Zee
on February 02, 2011
thanks Zee, this makes sense.... apparently this replacement involves getting to the problem....service center said it was a 4 hour job.. i guess that why is so expensive.... thanks again. donwalters
on February 02, 2011
Yes, they are correct. Make sure they will replace the hoses also.

Zee
on February 02, 2011
zee, you certainly are a reliable source.....ie
read your suggestion
went home for lunch.
parked in drive, engine on, remove oil cap
and whatda you know....
it had a 'magnet feel' to the cap held above the oil thing hole.
or at least like a gravity pull.

thanks to you, my mechanics suggestions are confirmed.

thanks to you and repair pal...donwalters

ps im trying to nurse 300000+ miles outta this ole ride...hopefully this pcv valve thing works toward that end.
RepairPal estimates are guaranteed at over 2,000 quality certified locations nationwide. Learn more

Similar Questions

View answers to similar questions from RepairPal's community of auto experts and enthusiasts.
there is not a pcv valve on my valve cover inside or out. Should there be one,is my question?
With the cold weather recently my car is having issues wanting to start and stay on. When I start my 05 Ford Taurus u...
Didn't find what you were looking for?