RepairPal is your advocate for car care advice and guidance

Q: I think I have a bad mechanic? Does this sound legitimate? on 2001 Volkswagen Beetle

Rookie cbe0621eac06868b3efe0d8d1d3611e23c60d3114864ea2ec19a68cfbd3eebab
So, I am having major issues with my 2001 VW beetle. Over the past 3 years, I have replaced the mass air sensor, coolent temp. sensor, knock sensor (twice within 3 years), timing belt, belt tensioner, roller, break caliber- front, and 4 coils. I'm sure there are more parts, I just can't remember them.
My car is acting up once again-- by the way, the second knock sensor and the 4 coils were replaced this past week. My mechanic is blaming on a "bad coincidence" that I picked up my car from his shop last night, drove it twice and then it wouldn`t start. It won`t even turn over, but the lights and radio are working fine, so it is not the battery. The mechanic is saying it is my starter that has gone out now. I have about 134,000 miles on it.
I don`t know what to do. Should I believe him? Is it really just a coincidence that this all happens with a new mechanic and all within 2 weeks? How much does a starter cost? I have already paid him over $700 for the coils and knock sensor.'.
No car image 94a1663db56199c5353592009e34aaa51078a2469bed068bb8d6f0ba43accf97
Get a Repair Estimate
Guaranteed by certified locations nationwide. Learn more
RepairPal estimates are guaranteed at over 1,700 quality certified locations nationwide. Learn more
first of all, if you have no cofidence in him, go somewhere else for another opinion.
you can use our estimator tab at the top to get prices in your area for the starter.
why did you replace all those sensors?? was there an issue at that time??

Yes, there were multiple issues. At some points it was just my check engine light and those sensors are what they determined needed to be changed. Other times my brakes were not working right, and still at others my car wouldn't accelerate properly. Do you think it is the starter? Or should I just take it to someone else to make sure.. it is at his shop now.
If the problems were repaired correctly by him than stay with him. It seems that he fixed the problems. Timing belt and brakes are regular maintenance and wear items anyway.
And yes, it could be the starter.

I have seen many VW Bugs with a LOT more problems than your car is having. They are not a well built, trouble free cars.
You can always have the option to get a second opinion from another mechanic, however it seems these cars are turning into a money pit over 100K miles.

Didn't find what you were looking for?