GMC Sierra 1500 vs. Toyota Tacoma

Compare repair costs, reliability, and owner reviews

GMC Sierra 1500

$727
Average Annual
Repair Cost

Toyota Tacoma

$478
Average Annual
Repair Cost

Overall Reliability Rating

3
1
2
Above Average
The GMC Sierra 1500 Reliability Rating is 3.5 out of 5.0, which ranks it 3rd out of 17 for fullsize trucks. The average annual repair cost is $727 which means it has average ownership costs. While repairs tend to be more severe than average, the number of those issues is low, so major repairs are uncommon for the Sierra 1500.
3
1
2
Above Average
The Toyota Tacoma Reliability Rating is 3.5 out of 5.0, which ranks it 7th out of 7 for midsize trucks. The average annual repair cost is $478 which means it has lower than average ownership costs. While repairs tend to be more severe than average, the number of those issues is low, so major repairs are uncommon for the Tacoma.
Cost
Average annual repairs total
$727
inexpensive
expensive
$478
inexpensive
expensive
Frequency
Average annual repair shop visits
0.2
not often
very often
0.25
not often
very often
Severity
Percentage of annual repairs that are urgent
15%
not urgent
urgent
17%
not urgent
urgent

Overall Car Ratings & Details

5 (4)
4 (22)
3 (14)
2 (2)
1 (2)
The GMC Sierra 1500 ranks highest in value and ranks lowest in value.
“Our Sierra Denali 2005 extended cabin is as comfortable as a luxury sedan, very roomy in the back, the kids love to watch their favorites DVD movies on the rear seats entertainment system. With its...”
“Our Sierra Denali 2005 extended cabin is as comfortable as a luxury sedan, very roomy in the...”
5 (12)
4 (42)
3 (10)
2 (1)
1 (1)
The Toyota Tacoma ranks highest in value and ranks lowest in value.
“This Tacoma has been an exceptionally reliable truck. Comfortable and quiet inside (still after 100K), nice factory Toyota sound system. Consistent good gas mileage for a truck (24MPG). Manual...”
“This Tacoma has been an exceptionally reliable truck. Comfortable and quiet inside (still after...”

Vehicle Comparison Rundown

The GMC Sierra 1500 and the Toyota Tacoma are both body-on-frame pickup trucks, but they reside in two different size classes. The GMC Sierra 1500 is a full-size pickup, and the Toyota Tacoma is a midsize pickup. This means that there will be differences in power, size, interior space, towing, hauling and features, usually in the favor of the larger, full-size Sierra 1500.

The differences start with their standard engines. The GMC Sierra 1500 starts with 285 horsepower, and the smaller Toyota Tacoma opens with 159 horsepower. Optional engines top out at 420 horsepower for the Sierra 1500, while the Tacoma has a 278-horsepower upgrade.

There are also some major differences between the payload and towing capacities of the GMC Sierra 1500 and the Toyota Tacoma. The full-size Sierra 1500 can tow up to 12,500 pounds, and has a maximum payload of 2,250 pounds. The midsize Tacoma can tow up to 6,800 pounds, and has a maximum payload of 1,620 pounds. The Sierra 1500 can tow almost twice as much, and haul nearly 50% more weight than the Tacoma.

Choosing between the GMC Sierra 1500 and the Toyota Tacoma is all about what you need. If you need lots of towing and hauling capacity, the GMC Sierra 1500 is the better choice. If a trimmer, lighter-duty truck is all you require, then the Toyota Tacoma should have the qualities you are looking for.