Would you replace or rebuild a rear diff with 160k miles on it? on 2000 Audi S4

Rear diff gearings are going. I would rather rebuild it, but my mechanic wants to swap it out with a used one. Anybody have a source for rebuild kits or know of a shop in NorCal to do the work? Thanks

by in Belmont, CA on August 31, 2014
2 answers 4 comments
ANSWER by on August 31, 2014
Your guy is correct. Save money and get a good used one. Audi's usually don't have diff problems
COMMENT by on August 31, 2014
Thanks
ANSWER by on August 31, 2014
Swapping is cheaper but what condition it the used one in? No one knows until after it's installed. Do you know how many miles are on it? GL
COMMENT by on August 31, 2014
I have 157k miles on mine. It has a whine in it, and we changed oil about 2 months ago, and he said "see how long this lasts" The oscillation noise went away for a few weeks, but now I can really feel in grinding at all speeds. Will start to look for a replacement.
COMMENT by on September 01, 2014
Bearing noises don't go away and come back. Once a bearing is damaged it does not get quiet. Maybe you should have it checked again. Does the tone change when letting go of the throttle? If the noise changes while turning left or right, it could be a wheel bearing
COMMENT by on September 01, 2014
Thanks, we've checked, and it's not the wheel bearings or the CV's. I'll be looking for a replacement, Thanks.

Related Content