Is it necessary to replace the fan clutch motor when replacing the water pump or is the service department trying to rip me off
BMW Q&AAsk Your Question
2004 BMW 325Ci Question: water pump replacement
Answer #1ZeeTech February 20, 2011, 21:25Master
I believe you are talking about the thermo fan clutch. There is no motor involved.
No, if it functioning good it does not necessary to replace with the water pump.
Did they tell you what's wrong it it?
I'd get a second opinion.....
Answer #2jamsik February 20, 2011, 21:54Rookie
I THINK SO,THE BOOK READS IF NOT MISTAKEING YOUR SUPPOSE TO CHANGE THE FAN CLUTCH EVERY 30.000 MILES,IF YOU GOT HIGH MILIAGE MAKE EASY ON YOUSELF WHILE YOU GOT FAN OFF TO REPLACE THE FAN CLUTCH.OLD SAYING PAY ME NOW OR PAY ME LATER
ReplyZeeTech, February 20, 2011, 22:18Master
I have many regular clients with over 100K miles in their BMWs with the original fan clutch and they are working perfectly fine. Some had a replacement water pump - since I don't like and don't trust pumps with plastic impellers, so they were replaced by one with metal ones, but still uses the original fan clutch.
I have seen failed clutches at 60-70 K, sometimes even at lower miles, but there is no regular replacement interval for those.
I have several BMW factory repair manual - I don't think I ever read about a 30K replacement interval, but I''ll check them tomorrow when I'll be at the shop.