Profile_thumbnail
 Enthusiast

Enthusiast

61 points

More About Points »

Bimmernut

Prescott, AZ

Enthusiast


Recent Activity

Questions & Answers | Problem Reports | Reviews | Comments

Question Answered: 

This sounds familiar. Following a quite detailed assessment by two different mechanics at my shop (which I trust), the conclusion was that the slight knocking sound I'd been hearing was actually most likely coming from the transmission and was most likely benign, especially if it doesn't get louder over time. The Getrag transission is supposed to be quite bulletproof. The most probably explanation (from the shop's senior technician, with 25 years experience, much of it with BMW) was that the sound was due to play between the gears themselves (being moved by the residual effect of the driveshaft still spinning), since the sound disappears under load. In other words, coming to a stop in neutral or with the clutch pedal depressed there is the slight knocking sound, but with the transmission engaged and under load (either accelerating or decelerating) the sound is not apparent. Hope this is helpful. I've decided not to worry, as long as the sound does not change or get worse (and so far, after 3,000 miles with the car, it hasn't)...


Flag This
Answer Ranks