Surgical Auto Repair, Inc.

(914) 595-5894
44 Verified Reviews

8:00am to 6:00pm
8:00am to 6:00pm
8:00am to 6:00pm
8:00am to 6:00pm
8:00am to 6:00pm


40 N Macquesten Pkwy
Mount Vernon, NY 10550 USA


  • Donald & Sandra Robinson, Owners
  • Established 1995
  • 2 Auto Repair Mechanics on Staff
  • 42 Years of Car Repair Experience

Surgical Auto Repair, Inc. Reviews


44 Verified Reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
by - Verified Customer April 09, 2017

There is no one else I'd trust with my vehicle.

by - Verified Customer March 30, 2017

Excellent customer service and honesty!

by - Verified Customer March 23, 2017

I was concerned that I needed brakes, I was right. And I needed service required at 50,000 miles. So I was able to get everything done the same day. I go to this repair shop because Sandra and Donald keep up with my cars service record. Nothing is ever done on my Cadillac unless it is fully explained to me in advance. I'm a customer of 10 years. Plan to always use this repair shop.

by - Verified Customer March 12, 2017

My truck needed a diagnosis . then Sandra explain to me what major work that needed to be done first in order for my truck to stay on the road..

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer February 21, 2017

I have been a customer for over 10 years and only have the best to say about Sandra and Donald.

by - Verified Customer February 14, 2017

I received a ride home when the car had to kept overnight in the shop. I greatly appreciated that!

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer February 01, 2017

I have had an elderly Saab and two BMW serviced by Surgical. Rely on their expertise, their welcoming attitude and I would never go elsewhere. I'd highly recommend them.

by - Verified Customer January 26, 2017

Great Job. Thank you.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer January 17, 2017

They took longer to fix the car than anticipated because of computer issues. Donald was having a little bit of a problem troubleshooting all the codes that were revealed. But overall I was satisfied with the experience.

by - Verified Customer January 12, 2017

I feel robbed and betrayed after dealing with these people honestly. Get a second opinion before going through with anything here. Most repair shops will trick you out of cash if they can. Do your research.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer January 09, 2017

Everything was done without a hitch

by - Verified Customer December 19, 2016


+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer December 18, 2016

My experience at Surgical was a very good on all my visits. They are very reasonable and friendly establishment.

by - Verified Customer December 01, 2016

The employees was very organized, courteous, and knowledgeable. Sandra really knows her business.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer November 21, 2016


by - Verified Customer November 16, 2016

Shop has had car for over 2 months. Their customer service gave misleading time frames for repair to be completed. They missed every deadline that they gave, their call back was terrible that I was the person calling them instead. They have been caught out in many lies. I have paid thousands work and car had to go back to them as car was not fixed the first time.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer November 09, 2016

Continue to receive very good service!!!

by - Verified Customer February 20, 2014

I received the most courteous and accurate service on my truck. I know that my family is safe.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer February 12, 2014

They are just very good, honest and fair people.

by February 06, 2014

They did very good work.

+ Show more reviews
by January 28, 2014

The work is good but it is slow. I had to wait for the car.

by - Verified Customer November 26, 2013

Crystal pricing. Very thorough assessment. He talks you through what you need done. They do not try to press anything that is not needed.

+ Show more reviews
by October 31, 2013

They were very nice. It was done quickly.

by - Verified Customer October 30, 2013

The service is fast. The staff is friendly. They get the job done.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer October 18, 2013

They provide superb service. They are quick.

by - Verified Customer October 11, 2013

They have a good service. They gave me a time frame to be completed and they did that. I had to bring it back because the part was not good. They called the company to get a new part and they got it put into my car.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer October 09, 2013

They repaired it right the first time. They have great customer service. They are very personable.

by - Verified Customer October 07, 2013

They did the job that I wanted them to do and the price was reasonable, and overall I was satisfied.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer October 04, 2013

I simply think that the providers were very easy to work with. The service was good.

by - Verified Customer September 25, 2013

Service is satisfactory.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer September 23, 2013

They do a good job. They get it fixed for you.

by - Verified Customer September 10, 2013

The work was not done that well. Everything was talked about but they did not do all the things they said they would. I would not go back. We talked about everything that needed to be done but they did not do all the things they said they were going to do. Their prices are way too high. I would not go back.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer September 06, 2013

They are a great repair shop. They treat you like a member of the family. They do a great job. They always do their best to be sure I am satisfied.

by - Verified Customer August 28, 2013

They are very open and honest. They are friendly. They go over what they are going to do and if they need to change anything they call you and ask if it is okay.

+ Show more reviews
by - Verified Customer August 16, 2013

They were pretty clear on what they were going to fix and they fixed it. The price was not bad.

by - Verified Customer August 13, 2013

They do what they are supposed to do. They are honest. They do the work in a reasonable amount of time. They do not do unnecessary repairs.

+ Show more reviews
by August 06, 2013

They were reliable. They were quick. They were reasonable on the price.

7 verified customers did not leave comments but provided these ratings:
by Idisha, Marleneand 1 other verified reviewer
by 3 verified reviewers
by 1 verified reviewer



  • AC/Heating
  • Alignment
  • Check Engine Light
  • Diagnosis
  • Hybrid/Electric
  • Mobile Repair
  • Muffler & Exhaust
  • Oil Change & Lube
  • Roadside Assistance
  • Scheduled Maintenance
  • Service & Repair
  • Smog/Emissions Testing
  • Timing Belts
  • Tire Sales/Repair
  • Transmission Repair
  • Windshield/Glass
+ More


  • Car Delivery
  • Car Pickup/Dropoff
  • Car Wash
  • Coffee
  • Early Bird Dropoff
  • Extended/Evening Hours
  • Financing
  • Free Estimates
  • Gas/Diesel
  • Heated Waiting Room
  • Rental Car
  • Service Guarantee
  • Shopping Nearby
  • Shuttle
  • Towing
  • Warranty Accepted
+ More


  • ASA
  • Bosch Service Network
  • iATN


Surgical Auto Repair (SAR) is an established Auto Repair shop offering complete Domestic & Foreign Car Repair and Diagnostic Service, as well as Glass Installation and Tire Replacement. SAR has been servicing Mount Vernon, Yonkers, the Bronx, Scarsdale, and surrounding Westchester areas for more than 18 years. We differentiate ourselves by employing well-trained technicians and offering incredible value to customers who needs their cars fixed right, the first time.

We at SAR have attracted and maintained a loyal customer base through their customer-oriented focus. All employees are trained and held responsible for providing superior service and developing a long lasting bond with customers. This is very important in an industry where TRUST and HONESTY are what customers want most.

The Auto Repair industry is very competitive,but we have differentiated ourselves by not only offering a worry-free repair experience, but also performing top notch-diagnostics along with glass installation and tire replacement.
Not only will this serve a wide range of customers for both service and diagnostic, but the glass and tire department will support the community in a large aspect and will make it a one stop service shop.

We also offer Unlimited Shuttle Service to our customers.

We are proud to be a one-stop service shop.


  • Acura
  • Audi
  • BMW
  • Buick
  • Cadillac
  • Chevrolet
  • Chrysler
  • Dodge
  • FIAT
  • Ford
  • GMC
  • Geo
  • Honda
  • Hummer
  • Hyundai
  • Infiniti
  • Isuzu
  • Jaguar
  • Jeep
  • Kia
  • Land Rover
  • Lexus
  • Lincoln
  • Mazda
  • Mercedes-Benz
  • Mercury
  • Mini
  • Mitsubishi
  • Nissan
  • Oldsmobile
  • Plymouth
  • Pontiac
  • Porsche
  • Ram
  • Saab
  • Saturn
  • Scion
  • Smart
  • Subaru
  • Suzuki
  • Toyota
  • Volkswagen
  • Volvo
+ More

RepairPal Scorecard


Surgical Auto Repair is run by husband and wife duo, Donald and Sandra Robinson. This RepairPal Certified shop was established as and has been family owned and operated since 1995. Donald Robinson is a very experienced industry professional who continually attends high quality ongoing training to help ensure that professional repairs are made to your modern vehicle. Some of the recent training includes Mercedes Benz and Advanced European diagnosis updates. Sandra is the service advisor and takes great care to make sure your experience is a good one, this was confirmed in our unbiased review of their recent customers. They describe this RepairPal Certified shop as reliable, accurate, courteous, efficient, and honest. Their work is backed by a 12-month / 12,000-mile warranty for your peace of mind. Local shuttle service, early bird drop off, and a clean comfortable waiting area with wireless Internet are all available for your convenience.

Get Directions to Surgical Auto Repair, Inc.