Jon, based on what you have said the radiator had a leak, you replaced the radiator. It has fresh coolant and a new radiator. If the engine temperature gets up to operating temperature and your heater works well then the thermostat is operating correctly in the closed position. If the temprature reaches half way or a little over half way as you drive the car the thermostat is opening correctly. I would wait until the coolant needed to be drained or the cooling system was being worked on in the future to replace the thermostat.