Oil Filter Housing Gasket - How Critical - If Leak Small on 1999 BMW 328i

If I am not losing a lot of oil how critical is it to change the Oil Filter Housing Gasket. Per dealer inspection, they recommended I do this right away for around $900. From my perspective it is cheaper to add a quart of oil between oil change intervals. It is a the bottom of the engine and seems to leave minimum oil residue on the engine top. However, I do not know if this will lead to a massive oil leak and potentially leave me stranded somewhere with the "Oil Light"? Also, can any competent mechanic do this or does this require BMW specific knowledge (i.e. do I need to have this done at a dealership)?

by in Santa Monica, CA on November 07, 2009
Get Your Car Fixed at a RepairPal Certified Shop.
We certify shops based on expertise, quality work, and verified customer reviews
3 answers 1 comment
ANSWER by , August 27, 2010
i know some place downtown that will do it for 60 and they know bmw
COMMENT by , November 29, 2010
Can i get the name and number for this place?
ANSWER by , April 18, 2010
I as well had the same problem, I didnt change it cause of the price and the leak just kept getting worse and worse till I finaly had to have it changed it went on for a couple years so I dont think its that critical. you know how mechanics are everything's a big deal cause they want your money! and no you dont need an authorised mechanic just a compitant one, cause they have to take the top half of the motor off, it is a pain in the rear end though, but my guy charged me $150 for that you can do it yourself but it would probably take all day
ANSWER by , November 08, 2009
i had a similar leak on this car myself i use a stop leak and it worked fine after a couple of thousand miles the leak when away.