My truck isn't starting after replacing the starter, need troubleshooting help? on 1990 Toyota Pickup

Have 1989(not 4x4). Went to start it and starter wasn't working. I replaced the starter and now nothing. Only clicks, Battery is charged, cables tight. Just getting a spinning sound when the starter spins. Is something wrong with new starter or do I need to look elsewhere?

by in Nehalem, OR on November 04, 2012
Get Your Car Fixed at a RepairPal Certified Shop.
We certify shops based on expertise, quality work, and verified customer reviews
3 answers
ANSWER by , November 04, 2012
something IS wrong with your starter.
ANSWER by , November 04, 2012
WHAT DID THE OLD STARTER ACT LIKE? NO SOUND, JUST CLICK OR WHAT? WITH TRANS IN PARK OR NET. AND PARK BRAKE ON JUMPER BATT. POS. TO SMALL WIRE ON STARTER ENG. SHOULD TURN IF BATT. FULL CHARGE AND CABLE GOOD! IF IT DOES NOT THEN STARTER IS DEFECTIVE!! USE A WIRE ABOUT 12 TO 14 GA. FROM BATT. POS. TO SMALL WIRE ON STARTER. IF YOU CAN, HOOK TO STARTER FIRST THEN TOUCH BATT. POS.
ANSWER by , November 04, 2012
Sounds like the starters drive is not engaging (not jumping out when it is energized). Remove and bench test