Is it normal to need the brake pads and rotors replaced at 34K? on 2005 Mini Cooper S

The invoice stated the brake pads were 5 mm.

by in Crofton, MD on January 14, 2010
Get Your Car Fixed at a RepairPal Certified Shop.
We certify shops based on expertise, quality work, and verified customer reviews
3 answers
ANSWER by , January 14, 2010
You need to know the original thickness of the pad to know what 5mm represents, if the pad is 10mm when new, then you have 50% remaining. Pads should be replaced at about 20%. The rotors have a minimum thickness as well, and if they are recommending rotors, they should state the measured thickness of the rotor. If you have vibration from the brakes, then you may need rotors no matter the thickness measured. It sounds like they are over selling this job and you don't quite need brakes yet, I would get a second opinion, and/or ask for a better justification as to why the pads and rotors need replacement.
ANSWER by , March 21, 2010
This was suggested to me as well. I purchased the extended warranty and the dealer was very happy to replace it...of course. My car was at 55k miles.
ANSWER by , March 25, 2010
i change mine like around every 10k to 15k so don't even worry a bit haha