Is it a good upgrade to get a 2006 Lexus is250, or a 2011 Toyota Camry? on 1995 BMW 325i

My 1995 BMW 325i was currently wrecked. I want something similar because I liked the feel of how it drives, but I need something more reliable and a little lower maintenance costs. Would a Lexus be considered better than the BMW I have now, or would a Toyota be a more wise choice?

Asked by for the 1995 BMW 325i
MY opinion....Toyota , but I would suggest a look at 'Consumer Reports Used Car Buyers Guide' and compare.