If the old oil was thickened from overuse, the tapping noise could have been damped some by the oil. Fresh oil would be thinner and might allow more noise to be heard. If the 'slight tapping' is in the top of the engine, it's probably valve noise. If it's lower, it's probably a piston noise. If it were a harder knocking, it would be a crankshaft ('lower end') noise. Slight valve noise is usually not much concern, but the lower in the engine and louder it is, the more concern. You may want to bring it to a GM specialist for a second opinion.
If you want to find a specialist, here's a directory link for you:
https://repairpal.com/directory?address=20748&car_brand_n...