I am a little unsure of your problem. I read it as your l/r window rolls down by itself whenever it feels like it - how often does this happen? I am assuming the window rolls back up normally. There are three modules involved in your l/r window. The drivers window switch, the body control module, and the l/r window switch. The l/r switch has already been replaced so that leaves only two. A stray signal from either the drivers switch or the BCM is probably causing your problem. Viewing BCM data with a scan tool while the fault is occurring may be the only way to determine the exact cause of the problem.